What Makes You No Longer a Baby Bat?

So I’m sat at work, listening to Cemetery Confessions‘ Facing Nostalgia series where the two lovely goth hosts Dani and Trae, and knowledgeable, musically inclined special guests Azy Batz of Obscura Undead ans Ryan Flint of Witch Hands discuss goth and goth adjacent bands from when they were first discovering what their favourite flavors of goth music would come to be. And I thought to myself, when do goths actually get out of the baby bat stage?
There are probably TONS of answers to this question, but of course I’m going to throw my own bat into the ring.
When I first entered the actual goth scene, around 16 years old, I was overwhelmed with how much history is behind what I deemed a very niche genre of music. Peter Murphy this, Andrew Eldritch that; where do I start?? I knew I really gravitated to Siouxsie’s Spellbound song, so I started researching the album online, then the band, then ’similar bands’, and I rabbit-holed from there. And even with some new found knowledge at my ready-to-talk-to-other-goths arsenal, I still felt like something was missing. Like, I didn’t understand why I still felt like an outsider. So, I joined some goth Facebook groups and started lurking around. I wanted to understand more about goth from an everyday goth rather than just reading about it (although reading about it then and now is still gravely important to me).
At some point, I built up enough confidence to start posting my own OOTDs, goth memes, discussions, etc. And I noticed that although I was getting some traction, I would sometimes get people in the comments referencing lyrics from songs or my outfit and makeup remind them of X singer from X band. Agh! Felt like I went right back to square one with not understanding anything. And now looking back, I loved getting comments like that because it forced me to research more into the scene. Who is this person? How did they influence goth? And it got to a point (around 20 years old) where I felt SO comfortable talking about goth and who is who, what is what, etc. etc. Enough that I even made a whole blog about it.
BUT!!! All of this still doesn’t answer the question: when is a goth no longer a baby bat? Age is usually the answer I see the most, but I’d argue that it boils down to knowledge and having the willingness to learn. I’ve seen older goths with limited knowledge of the scene, and younger Gen Z and Gen Alpha that are as knowledgeable, and in some cases more than their elder goth counterparts.
Alright hold on, hold on. Before you obliterate me, I‘m aware of the differences in access to knowledge, limiting circumstances, etc. and that’s understandable. Technically, we’re all still in the learning phases of what makes goth goth: the philosophical goth question no one truly knows the answer to. That being said, I do believe that it’s important to know that you are NOT less goth because of your knowledge, rather I‘m just trying to say to always keep learning and stay open minded. What could be goth today may not tomorrow (i.e some older goths debate on whether or not Marilyn Manson is goth), and viewpoints on ethnicity, sexuality, gender expression, etc. in the goth scene will always change to better include everyone, even if we grew up on limiting beliefs that some have now carried into the scene.
I‘m sure someone smarter than me could answer this better with more tact, but I guess by my logic we are all baby bats to some extent. I’ll put it this way; age is not what makes you old, refusing to learn and grow does.


